Skip to content
Contact
Set Up A Call
  • Blog
  • What’s a Dispatchable Energy Credit and What Does It Accomplish?
Share this post
John Bonnin

John Bonnin

What’s a Dispatchable Energy Credit and What Does It Accomplish?

October 12, 2022
/
Transmission Outage Management

Most of the electric power industry followed Texas winter storm Uri and the associated rolling outages in February 2021. Millions of customers were without power for extended periods. Sub-freezing temperatures lasted for days. Water systems dependent upon electricity for pressure control also failed, leaving many without water as well. Over 100 Texans died as a direct result.

The storm happened when the Texas legislature was in session — a rather odd coincidence since the legislature only meets every other year and then for only a few months. Reaction from the legislature was swift: The Public Utility Commission of Texas (PUCT) was commissioned to examine the current rules under which the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) handles the power market in Texas and improve these rules to ensure this type of catastrophe does not repeat.

Among the dozens of concerns that have come out since the disaster is the idea that Texas may be too dependent on intermittent power sources, namely, wind and solar power. Due to freezing issues, some wind power facilities did not generate during the storm. Solar was likewise curtailed due to the heavy snow that fell across the state. Had more reliable, dispatchable power been available, the reasoning goes, the state could have overcome the issues with the intermittent sources.

The actual root causes of the power emergency went far beyond renewable energy underperformance; there were shortages of natural gas for power generation, some power plants tripped offline in the low temperatures, and so on. But the dispatchable generation of power was clearly seen as an issue.

Dispatchable energy meaning

Dispatchable energy can be programmed quickly on-demand by power grid operators. As a result, dispatchable energy is ready for use when the market is in need. In contrast, non-dispatchable energy refers to renewable energy sources, such as solar and wind, which can’t be sourced when needed.

Dispatchable Energy Credits

PUCT proposed a recommendation to set up a system for incentivizing the investment in power infrastructure that’s truly dispatchable. The concept is that Load Serving Entities (LSEs) must show that a certain percentage of their load obligation is covered by firm, dispatchable power (instead of intermittent power). This process would essentially create a Dispatchable Portfolio Standard for LSEs.

Dispatchable Energy Credit definition

These LSEs could satisfy the standard by purchasing or generating Dispatchable Energy Credits (DECs). These credits are awarded to owners of certified dispatchable energy resources — thermal power plants, energy storage devices, and other qualifying resources. If an LSE owns such resources, they can self-satisfy the portfolio requirement, but if they don’t have enough, they could purchase these from other market participants who have excess.

The intent behind creating the DECs is to incentivize the investment of power-generating resources that are dispatchable when needed and not dependent on natural forces like the sun and wind to produce power. Presumably, if there’s an overall shortage of DECs in the market, their price will rise, leading investors to view DECs as an additional revenue stream for a potential project.

This approach is identical to one taken in the early 2000s with the adoption of the Renewable Energy Portfolio Standard in Texas. Load-serving entities had to satisfy a specific portion of their power requirements with renewable energy. Renewable Energy Credits (RECs) were awarded to wind and solar farms; these were purchased by the LSEs to satisfy the portfolio standard, and the highly successful renewable energy portfolio in Texas got off the ground. The extra revenue stream provided by the RECs enabled many projects to be accomplished that would not have otherwise succeeded.

Are there issues with DECs?

The first issue to address is: What resources would qualify to be awarded DECs? Initially, the guidance applies only to new generation resources. Further, the suggestion is that the resources must be able to ramp up to full load in five minutes or less and have a heat rate of 8,000 British thermal units/ kilowatt-hours or less. For batteries, there is a two-hour duration minimum to qualify.

These requirements sound reasonable, but if it only applies to new generation, then the vast majority of ERCOT’s current dispatchable fleet would not qualify. Further, with the DEC program only addressing new generation, what portfolio standard would then apply to LSEs? Would the PUCT set a goal of 3,000 megawatts of new generation and distribute the goal among the LSEs based on load ratio share? What about LSEs that have their obligation completely covered by existing dispatchable resources — will they be forced to purchase DECs nevertheless?

The five-minute requirement has also been questioned — how much more effective is this than the current 10-minute requirement for qualifying for Responsive Reserve Service (RRS)? Many quick-start combustion turbines can meet the 10-minute requirement but will not reach the five-minute goal. Similarly, the 8,000 Btu/kWh heat rate target isn’t achievable for most quick-start combustion turbines, which operate around 9,000-9,400 Btu/kWh. These two criteria eliminate some of the most flexible resources in the market and the ones most easily sited, permitted, and quickly constructed.

A more significant issue revolves around how much of an incentive the DECs will actually be. It’s proposed that the DEC procurements be limited to 12 months in advance. Some market participants believe this doesn’t offer enough revenue certainty required by lenders and other capital investors. A given project’s economics revert to basic calculations related to the forward price curve, probability of scarcity pricing, and other issues currently unfavorable to new investment.

Where from here?

The PUCT is currently working with consultants to develop a partial redesign for the ERCOT market in at least a few areas. The targeted aspects are reforms to the Operational Reserve Demand Curve (ORDC) price formation mechanism to increase prices when the market approaches scarcity conditions. Adjustments to how LSEs ensure their load obligation is covered by firm generation; enhancing the role of Demand Response (DR) in the market and reforming the method for deploying Emergency Reserve Service (ERS); and several other areas. Implementing some type of Dispatchable Energy Credit program is among the future changes being analyzed.

The proposed reforms to the market will undoubtedly stir much debate and analysis in the coming months and years. Some actions will be easy and quick to implement, while others will take more time. The eventual state of the market may not even contain Dispatchable Energy Credits. But faced with a rapidly growing market, the Texas grid must evolve and adapt to ensure no repeat of the sweeping power outages that crippled the state in 2021.

Interested in more content about ERCOT? Read John Bonnin’s blog post, “Energy Storage Integration In the Texas Power Market.”

John Bonnin

John Bonnin

John Bonnin has over 30 years of power industry experience, including managing market risks to native load customers and optimal dispatch of power generation fleets. His diverse experience includes natural gas price risk management, distributed energy resources, power marketing and trading, and renewable energy contracts.

Related blog posts

Loading...
Dec 07
Transmission Outage Management

Can a Machine Learn to Manage Your Outages?

transmission lines with an orange sky
Nov 02
Australia,Transmission Outage Management

Leverage an Enterprise Platform to Streamline Your Outage Management Workflows

Jul 13
Generation Outage Management,Transmission Outage Management

What’s the Difference Between a Work Management System and Outage Management System?

Related press

Loading...
Laptop computer with code displayed on the screen
Jan 23
Cybersecurity

PCI Successfully Completes SOC/FISMA Examinations for 2022

Ron Swartz, senior director of Trading Analytics, at PCI Energy Solutions
Jan 11

Energy Trading Product Visionary Ron Swartz Joins PCI Energy Solutions

Transmission Lines
Nov 16
SEEM

Multiple Customers Go Live With the PCI SEEMTrader Platform for Autonomous Power Trading in the Southeast Energy Exchange Market (SEEM)

PCI Energy Solutions

PCI Energy Solutions

Also known as Power Costs, Inc.

Connect with us

U.S. 1+ 405.447.6933

Sales 1+ 405.701.7301

301 David L. Boren Blvd., Suite 2000
Norman, OK 73072

Contact us

We’re Hiring! 

Linkedin Twitter
  • Energy Trading and Optimization
  • Wholesale Market Participation
  • ETRM
  • Portfolio Optimization
  • Settlements and Billing
  • Gas & Fuels Management
  • Generation Outage Management
  • Company Type
  • Utilities
  • Generators
  • Traders
  • Renewable Energy
  • Asset Managers
  • Retailers
  • About
  • About Us
  • Cybersecurity
  • Leadership
  • Our Technology
  • Newsroom
  • Careers

Subscribe to our newsletter

Subscribe
  • Transmission and Reliability
  • Transmission Outage Management
  • Transmission Scheduling
  • e-Tagging
  • Balancing Authority Operations
  • Energy Accounting
  • Settlements and Billing
  • Sustainable Energy
  • Renewables Trading & Scheduling
  • Energy Storage Optimization & Trading
  • Hydrogen
  • Hydropower
  • Carbon Intensity
  • Markets
  • US ISO/RTO Markets
  • US Bilateral Markets
  • Canada
  • Chile
  • Mexico
  • Europe
  • Australia
  • Thought Leadership
  • Blog
  • Webinars & Events
  • Customer Portal
  • INFOCUS Conference
  • Product Trainings
  • Product Documentation
  • Issue Tracker

© Power Costs, Inc. 2022 | All Rights Reserved.

  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
Manage Cookie Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}

Request More Information

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Contact

Name(Required)
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Subscribe

Name
I am not a robot 🤖

Solutions

Energy Trading and Optimization

  • Wholesale Market Participation
  • ETRM
  • Portfolio Optimization
  • Settlements and Billing
  • Gas & Fuels Management
  • Generation Outage Management
  • Wholesale Market Participation
  • ETRM
  • Portfolio Optimization
  • Settlements and Billing
  • Gas & Fuels Management
  • Generation Outage Management

Transmission and Reliability

  • Transmission Outage Management
  • Transmission Scheduling
  • e-Tagging
  • Balancing Authority Operations
  • Settlements and Billing
  • Energy Accounting
  • Transmission Outage Management
  • Transmission Scheduling
  • e-Tagging
  • Balancing Authority Operations
  • Settlements and Billing
  • Energy Accounting

Sustainable Energy

  • Renewable Energy Trading & Scheduling
  • Energy Storage Optimization & Trading
  • Hydrogen
  • Hydropower
  • Carbon Intensity
  • Renewable Energy Trading & Scheduling
  • Energy Storage Optimization & Trading
  • Hydrogen
  • Hydropower
  • Carbon Intensity

Markets

  • US ISO/RTO Markets
  • US Bilateral Markets
  • Canada
  • Mexico
  • Chile
  • Europe
  • Australia
  • US ISO/RTO Markets
  • US Bilateral Markets
  • Canada
  • Mexico
  • Chile
  • Europe
  • Australia

Resources

Thought Leadership

  • Blog
  • Webinars & Events
  • Blog
  • Webinars & Events

Customer Portal

  • INFOCUS Conference 2023
  • Product Trainings
  • Product Documentation
  • Issue Tracker
  • INFOCUS Conference 2023
  • Product Trainings
  • Product Documentation
  • Issue Tracker

About Us

  • About
  • Leadership
  • Newsroom
  • Our Technology
  • Cybersecurity
  • About
  • Leadership
  • Newsroom
  • Our Technology
  • Cybersecurity

Careers

Contact Us